Leonard Wood Underground
heart and soul of our community
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Leonard Wood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
PCSing? Win the lottery? Explore homes near Ft. Leonard Wood courtesy of Remilitary.com!

what is your input

who's talking here?

MsOpinionated 4
Colonel Angus 4
Hillary 1
heather 2
ItsBetterUDontKnow 4
Argentina 13
Just Laura 3
AmyK 4
Cailey 2
Leee 1
BabyDoll 3
skit 3

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites

Leee --- 15 years ago -

http://www.wsaw.com/mobi?storyid=119020944 

MsOpinionated --- 15 years ago -

Okay, so I BF all three of my kids, and the oldest two (boys) did pretend to feed Emma's baby's "mommy milk" soo, I don't really see what the difference is between that kind of play that they pick up on their own, then having the doll. I think that the doll would be a great conversation piece between parent and child.

So I guess I just don't see an issue with it. 

Colonel Angus --- 15 years ago -

i think it's a terrible idea. if kids really want to imitate mommy then they can do so with any doll. while i agree that bfing is natural and something that shouldn't have to be hidden i think that kids should be told it's what mommies do to feed their babies. we don't need kids walking around playing house having other kids "drink" their milk. 

Hillary --- 15 years ago -

Opinions on the topic aside - Kids don't need a special doll to pretend to bf 

Argentina --- 15 years ago -

I think it is sad that it is seen as "weird"... no one looks twice if they see a child play mommy with a bottle. Kids imitate most things they see, if we want our kids to see breastfeeding as normal, then why not.
I wouldn't buy it because it's 100 freakin' dollars, since my babe can pretend-nurse anything, it doesn't have to be THIS specific doll. BlessedMama has a good point, it would be a great conversation starter. I can't tell you how many times young kids ask "what I'm doing" while I'm bfing, when it should be natural, something they already have seen and know to be natural. 

Colonel Angus --- 15 years ago -

i don't think there is anything natural about kids having a doll that sucks on their boobs. any regular doll is fine. if they see mommy bfing then of course they are going to want to imitate it. that's only natural. but do you really want your kids going to day care, preschool, kindergarten or playgroups and play bfing with their friends? i'm just saying there needs to be boundaries. 

Colonel Angus --- 15 years ago -

lee.. you posted the link. what do YOU think? 

Argentina --- 15 years ago -

Do kids even bring out dolls out to the playground? Granted, I don't know for sure, my daughter is only 1, no playground for her yet. :P 

heather --- 15 years ago -

Argentina- i think what she means by playing bfinding with their friends is the same as kids playing house... one is the mom one is the dad and then someone is the kid.. i THINK what she is asking is do you want your kids to act like they are bfeeding on another kid or vise versa..
I have nursed all 3 of my kids some longer than others. it is a natural thing and i know that they understand it.. however since there are so many dolls out there that make sounds when "sucking" a bottle it would be nice if there was a doll for those kids who know bfeeding is a natural thing that made a sucking noise. now would i go out and spend that kind of money on a doll uuuuhhhhhh NO but there are those parents who COULDNT nurse that may want to teach their kids about it and are reserved to the point that they would feel odd trying to teach their kids about it thru another person and for that i think this doll would be perfect. 

heather --- 15 years ago -

haha should say "bfeeding" not bfinding LOL 

AmyK --- 15 years ago -

I heard about this doll a few days ago and I think it is dumb. Why make your kids grow up any faster? Sure, it educates them on what "mommy" is doing but not all moms breastfeed. 

ItsBetterUDontKnow (Mod) --- 15 years ago -

but not all moms breastfeed

but, maybe more moms would breastfeed if it were encouraged at a younger age :) I have no shame in telling my daughter that babies are suppose to eat from their mommy's boob. She also knows that some mommy's can't, so they use bottles. I don't tell her "some mommy's don't want to, so they just don't" because that isn't the attitude I want her to have toward bf'ing.

as far as the doll ... it's just another doll. I wouldn't buy it regardless of the price, but imo, it's no different than any other toy little girls have. barbies, babies, play houses .... they all teach them to practice what it's like to be older. 

Just Laura --- 15 years ago -

but, maybe more moms would breastfeed if it were encouraged at a younger age

amen sista! 

AmyK --- 15 years ago -

I see your point Vanessa and Laura but I am one of those moms that "just didn't want to". I never had a desire to do it and it is not because I wasn't educated on it. I just preferred not to. I went to all sorts of classes when I was pregnant with our first son and I was always told that breastfeeding was best. I struggled with my decision for a while but I knew it would be no good for my son if I just did it to do it. I just don't see why they have to come out with a doll like this. 

Argentina --- 15 years ago -

dolls

these are really neat :) 

Argentina --- 15 years ago -

kids already grow up fast, and if the only thing they learn is that boobs are for fun because no one ever said otherwise, then that point of view is never going to change. Boobs are going to be kept for selling cars and beer. :P 

ItsBetterUDontKnow (Mod) --- 15 years ago -

kids already grow up fast, and if the only thing they learn is that boobs are for fun because no one ever said otherwise, then that point of view is never going to change. Boobs are going to be kept for selling cars and beer. :P

GREAT point. Little girls wear skimpy clothes, see womens' tata's hanging out, sex is EVERYWHERE for little girls. this is a very powerful opportunity to teach little girls, AND BOYS, that boobs serve a bigger purpose than getting beads at mardi gras. 

Argentina --- 15 years ago -

^^EXACTLY. If this doll (or any doll) were used to show how a body is supposed to function, then maybe the future generations would have a better understanding of it. No need to fear nature. Whether one chooses to bf or not, education/information is a powerful thing. 

Just Laura --- 15 years ago -

breastfeed 

Just Laura --- 15 years ago -

oh it does let me put it. I was just wondering since everyone is putting bf and bfeeding and what not :) 

MsOpinionated --- 15 years ago -

Breasts, are not "just" a sexual object, they actually are really supposed to serve a greater purpose,and back in the day, a woman with larger breasts was seen as someone who could more easily nourish her children.
((begin sarcasm))
But please, lets take this perfectly acceptable doll that has educational purposes, and push the sluttly bratz dolls with their teeny clothes, hooker shoes, and ridiculous make-up. Because I'd rather MY daughter be a tramp than learn that her breasts can be used for something other than wearing skimpy tops.

((end sarcasm)) 

Argentina --- 15 years ago -

lmao! 

ItsBetterUDontKnow (Mod) --- 15 years ago -

sluttly bratz dolls with their teeny clothes, hooker shoes, and ridiculous make-up

lol i'm actually giggling out loud at that 

BabyDoll --- 15 years ago -

I do not think that this doll should be sold. I am a mother of 3 children. When I had my first (boy) child I tried to breastfeed because everyone was saying how much better it is for the baby than formula. First off, I wasn't producing nearly enough for him and second off when I looked down and saw my SON latched on I felt disgusted. That is just my personal opinion. For the mother's who can breastfeed great but some people are not comfortable doing it or simply just can't. I just couldn't imagine a 5 or 6 year old girl playing house with this doll. Kids are growing up so fast as it is. Not to mention I would freak the f*ck out if my daughter was playing at a friends house with this doll and her friend had brothers. If you want to discuss the birds & bees, pregnancy & breastfeeding with your daughters that is great but at the right time. Let kids be kids and enjoy life while they can. 

Argentina --- 15 years ago -

The sad truth is that some women feel that bfing their baby is sexual, when it isn't. We were brought up to think that, to feel ashamed or embarrased of our breasts and how they are supposed to function. We weren't meant to feel that way about it. 

BabyDoll --- 15 years ago -

I wasn't brought up thinking that breastfeeding is sexual. My mom tried to breastfeed all of us but she couldn't produce enough so she had to bottle feed us. I know breastfeeding is natural but it just wasn't the right choice for me. Now, whenever the day comes that my daughter does get pregnant (which hopefully she will be in her 30's or 40's LOL) I will support whatever decision she makes on breastfeeding VS bottle feeding but that is her choice and no one else. 

AmyK --- 15 years ago -

I just think that a 4yr old is too young to "pretend" breastfeeding. My mom never raised me to think breastfeeding was sexual. I like babydoll just didn't feel comfortable doing it. I think breastfeeding advocacy can go too far. It makes us moms who choose not too feel like we are doing something wrong. I think it is great when a mom breastfeeds but I don't like it when us bottle moms are made to feel that we don't care about our babies. It has nothing to do with education...it is just all personal preference. 

MsOpinionated --- 15 years ago -

Its not about whether breastfeeding is the "right" choice or the ONLY choice. Its not.. and there are a million reasons one way or another that either choice could be made..

To ME it is about a little bit of DE-Sexualization of our children's bodies. MOST baby dolls are "bottle" babies. I don't see the problem with offering an alternative. Maybe it offends me that every baby doll out there has a bottle or a pacifier. (it doesn't, but I'm using that as an example.) 

AmyK --- 15 years ago -

Like I said...I think it is GREAT that moms breastfeed. I just don't think us moms who don't should be criticized for not doing it. You don't see me out there promoting and pushing bottle feeding. I really don't care if you breast feed or bottle feed. It is your choice. And I also think it is wrong when you see an older child doing it...like 3 yrs old. That is too old to be breastfeeding. Most children are off of the bottle and formula by the time they are one. so, with that said...I am done commenting on this subject. I don't agree with the doll and that is it. 

Argentina --- 15 years ago -

I don't think anyone was criticizing bottle-feeding, just normalizing breasts to be seen as food for babies, if the mom so chooses. 

page 1 2
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Leonard Wood Underground