Leonard Wood Underground
heart and soul of our community
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Leonard Wood bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
PCSing? Win the lottery? Explore homes near Ft. Leonard Wood courtesy of Remilitary.com!

Corporal Discipline (spanking) in school??????Hello???Is this real?

who's talking here?

Erin 1
MsOpinionated 1
Colonel Angus 3
Beth 5
Rebecca 1
Semperfiusmcwife 1
Jules 9
Jodie 1
Elizabeth 1
ItsBetterUDontKnow 1
Argentina 4
CHem bur lee 1
AudreyKeg 4
Monty 3
AmyK 9
Helena 10
Cailey 4
alanna 1
20160113meiqing 1
wqlyx 1

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites

Helena --- 15 years ago -

On my hunt for a pre- school I was recommended the Maranatha Baptist School. SO I called and they said they have space available. I am not Baptist but can be respectful.
So I am reading their handbook and Statement of Faith

http://www.maranatha-baptist.org/handbook.pdf

and I thought I didn't read proper.
They use corporal discipline!!!!
I am not sure if I am weird but where we come from that is illegal! Is this a Missouri law or what is this that this is permissible.

Then I read on and the teachers there are not even certified teachers but members of the church!!!

Does anyone have their kids in there? If so have you read that handbook??

Please enlighten me if this is "normal"!

Thanks! 

AmyK --- 15 years ago -

I too was thinking of sending our son there but after reading their handbook, I decided he was better off in public school. I don't know why anybody would send their child to a school that was not certified and did not have "real teachers". About the corporal punishment...I think that is normal in a baptist school. We are baptist and our church in NC used the same type of discipline. It mainly refers to spanking. While we don't agree with the spanking, a lot of christian pre-schools/churches recommend it.
The public schools around here aren't the greatest and if you have the willpower to homeschool, that would be the route to go:) 

Helena --- 15 years ago -

It can be found on page 5 and 8. 

Helena --- 15 years ago -

AmyK- I am in shock!! Really!! I am actually speechless. Do you think people do not read the handbook or that everyone is just ok with it. 

AmyK --- 15 years ago -

well believe it or not..a lot of parents agree with the corporal discipline. I know the Baptist school in NC would call the parents to come in and do the spanking when needed. I also think a lot of parents don't really read the handbook information, haha. My son went to two different preschools before moving here. One was baptist and one is presbytarian(sp). They both were great with him and he learned so much. At 3 and 4 yrs old, he was coming home reciting bible verses that I didn't even know. I know there is a lady on here with kids in that school and she has nothing but good things to say about it. I worry about the teachers not being certified. That is ridiculus. 

Jules --- 15 years ago -

Helena I'm with you. I am STRONGLY against physical punishment of any sort. I have never used it on my children and thought that it was illegal in all schools. Come on this is 2011 not 1850. But so many things are bass ackwards in this state and most other southern states, that I'm not surprised. 

Cailey --- 15 years ago -

Okay, I know that I am going to be in the minority here but from a licensed teacher's point of view...kids in school today are out of control. They are unfocused, lazy, and disrespectful. I'm not saying that every child is, just as a whole. When I was growing up, students respected the teachers, generally worked hard, and did as they were told. Now, things are different. Students know that in many cases the teacher's hands are tied in regards to discipline. I used to work at a school in NC. Corporal punishment was not allowed. The first year I taught there, we could make unruly students walk during recess for a maximum of 10 minutes. The 2nd year I was there, that rule had changed due to childhood obesity and the most we could do is isolation at lunchtime for a major offense (such as hitting a classmate). Now, if a student hit your child, would you want more than lunchtime isolation for the offender? I sure would. Schools nowadays are reluctant to expell students because large numbers of expulsions look unfavorably on year-end reports.
I also worked at a school in NC where corporal punishment was allowed. It was for MAJOR offenses only and even then it usually had to be for multiple offenses. In that school, the principal called the parent and basically said "You child did ________ at school today. They are either going to receive a spanking or be expelled." Most of the time, the parents opted for the spanking. And the students were much better behaved. Not because they were scared but they knew there were consequences to repeated bad behavior. I have never spanked a child and I would never spank a child that was not my own. However, when I send my child to school I expect that school to have a solid discipline plan in place. There are too many cases of unruly and disrespectful students and bullies in the world today. If your child is generally well behaved then he or she will never have to worry about getting a spanking in school. However, it actually can protect your child by deterring others from bullying him. 

Helena --- 15 years ago -

That was my first question/thought- what year are we in???Am I missing something? I guess I will have to learn and be open to more things when coming to FLW:)
I had a similar encounter when I was in a grocery store in S.C. when I wanted to buy a Kosher Red Wine. They told me I couldn't buy it. I thought they were joking and I told them I had my ID with me, they said they can't sell alcohol on Sundays. I still thought they are joking and told them to please stop messing around since I am in a hurry.
They took the bottle away and said it is the law - in the Bible belt no alcohol on Sundays ( except bars )
WOW!!!!! That was 8 years ago and I still can't get over it! 

Jules --- 15 years ago -

Wow teaching children to not be violent with violence. Sounds like a sound plan. What could possible go wrong with that???
While I agree not enough parents take responsability for their child. Non corporal style punishment should be up to the school and they should not bend to any parent. Even the annoying parent that thinks their hellion is a perfect angel (we all know that parent) 

Jules --- 15 years ago -

It's a major culture shock crossing the Mason Dixon line, ;) 

AmyK --- 15 years ago -

I too don't agree with spanking. There are other ways to discipline your child without spanking. We use the time out/toy taken away tactic. It works for the most part. Take my son for instance....he has a big problem with excessive talking in school. His teacher is always sending a "red note" home in his bag that we have to sign. We recently took his TV away from him (he only watches movies on it, no cable). We told him that until he can go a whole week without getting in trouble, then he can't have it back. This has been very hard for him because he loves watching his superhero movies. I will agree that kids get away with much more today then years ago but spanking them is not going to make it better. 

Helena --- 15 years ago -

Cailey- thank you for sharing! I do like to hear that side as well.
I think other ways of discipline need to be found. Spanking someone for hitting someone else is TO ME really getting on the same level as the student. Primitive.
Calling the parents and giving them the option whether to agree that they can spank your child or he is out is pretty much "forcing" them to agree.
Taking away recess I find is not a solution either.Kids need to get that energy out. But maybe give them extra duty like cleaning up.
Communication/counseling is the key between student / teacher/ parents.
If things do not improve the student needs to leave school.
This is just my personal opinion . 

Beth --- 15 years ago -

Corporal Punishment in school is actually not illegal in the state of Missouri. In fact it is legal in 21 states. You sign a paper when you register your child for school here. I'm not saying I agree with it, cause if someone is gonna spank my child it will be me. And yes Maranath does enforce and use corporal punishment. My friends kids went there until this last year, and her son was "spanked" every week. She is actually thinking of sending him back. Maranatha's curiiculum is way ahead of the public schools here though. 

Argentina --- 15 years ago -

on a lighter side... Which one of us have NEVER seen an unruly, annoying, obnoxious kid, and said "wow that kid needs an a$$ whooping!"..... or even an adult, for that matter! hahahah 

AudreyKeg --- 15 years ago -

When I was growing up in the military almost all the schools I went to, on and off post allowed spanking. I lived all over the US and in Germany. The only place that I actually got a spanking was in Germany. I don't remember what for but I'm sure I deserved it.

I'm the minority here but I believe in spanking. I think that it should only be a last resort. I know that some people don't believe in spanking but they will pop their kids in the mouth. I don't agree with that. BUT if it works for them, I'm not going to judge. Only you can judge what is best for your kid. 

Helena --- 15 years ago -

Argentina-agreed:)However that child needs a whooping from the parent not their non-certified teacher:)

Bethany- that is one of the reasons I asked, BECAUSE I heard positive things about Maranatha. It will not be an option for us but just wanted to know what the "normality" is there. Apparentlty it is not as shocking to all and quite common o some- now I know what to expect and not stand there with my mouth wide open when confronted with it. 

Helena --- 15 years ago -

@ Audrey
You got spanked in Germany? In a DODD's school ? Or a German school? 

AudreyKeg --- 15 years ago -

It was a Dodd school. 

Helena --- 15 years ago -

Audrey you don't look 110 years old:)
when it was common to do that:)

That is insane- this wouldn't fly these days anymore ,.......... or would it?!?!? 

Semperfiusmcwife --- 15 years ago -

My kid gets time out. If I don't spank her then no one does :) I would smack her butt before and it wasn't doing anything so i didn't want to hit harder so we do time outs and it works just fine. 

Beth --- 15 years ago -

Believe me when I say my friends son more than likely deserved to be spanked. That child need a good butt whooping.

Helena I don't think it is norm for it to happen everywhere in fact I don't know that many public schools or preschools for that matter enforce it. 

AmyK --- 15 years ago -

Bethany..I can't believe your friend allowed the school to spank her child every week. That is crazy. 

Argentina --- 15 years ago -

Just curious, what would be some suggestions for disciplining a pre-teen to an older teenager (at school by a teacher/authority figure)? 

Helena --- 15 years ago -

Take away their cell phones/internet/TV for a period of time or whatever it is they think they can't live without. 

Argentina --- 15 years ago -

I don't know, I went to HS in south Florida, and it seems that those kids were going to do whatever the hell they were going to do, even without their electronics... Seems impossible to discipline kids these days :( 

AmyK --- 15 years ago -

I will prob show my age a little here (graduated high school in late 90's) but when I was a teenager, we didn't have cell phones, laptops or fancy dancy cars. I remember using a payphone to "lie" to my parents about where I really was. It is so funny how teachers/schools today expect every child to have a computer at home. We never used a computer for homework. My son is in kindergarten and I am amazed of all the "recommended websites" he is suppose to practice on. what happened to good ole book teaching? 

Argentina --- 15 years ago -

Ah... my hubby brought up a great point: make them do community service, LEGITMATE community service. (the older ones) 

AmyK --- 15 years ago -

community service is definitly a thought, lol. 

Jodie --- 15 years ago -

Cailey-I totally feel for the teachers these days!! I do personally wish more parents WOULD opt for the corporal punishment when it's an option at school! When my daughter was younger, she went through some crap with some little boys in her class that had me up at the school in tears with the things they would say to her, write to her, and 'suggest' to her - I wanted to beat their butts myself, and all the principal would do was apologize for the parents that he couldn't get to take responsibility for their children!! I have always decided I would discipline my daughter myself, I feel like if she's behaving that bad that she needs a spanking, I will be the one doing it, but at the same time, it has been made very clear to her that if she gets in trouble at school, the trouble at home will be much worse!!! 

Erin (Mod) --- 15 years ago -

MO schools are allowed to use spanking as a punishment...even the ones on post...HOWEVER, it is up to the principal and school district whether or not they implement it and Waynesville does not. 

page 1 2 3
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...

advice
parenting

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Leonard Wood Underground